Recent Review; A Cold Shot of (Needed) Water

WhateverUSMC · 04-23-2010, 09:08 PM

I am somewhat in shock with the fact that the thread (with the link to the review) was closed. In reality, what was said in it was fairly accurate, and didn't contain anything that the players here haven't said before.

We now have a review that matches most, if not all, of the players complaints, and it just gets swept under a rug. Am I really the only one who has a problem with this?

The players get ignored. The reviewer gets silenced (5).

Mattdoesrock · 04-23-2010, 09:24 PM

What's the phrase..?

"Inb4lock"

?

Bladnoch · 04-23-2010, 09:37 PM

Wow, that is a shock...
I thought it was a pretty refreshing and honest review too - there was no ranting, no intended insults and no one completely and utterly disagreed with it, except NGD themselves, a reaction that speaks some volumes. :/

P.S. NGD, if you're going to close a thread which gives a less than average review of your game, do not stick it in the Complaint Book. There is a line between insults and harsh critique. A thin line, but please recognise it and tranfer the thread back to General Discussion...where it belongs.

Minorian · 04-23-2010, 09:49 PM

As soon as something goes against NGD, they just get rid of it. Whenever someone gives some criticism it is responded to often harshly, sometimes banning, sometimes dismissing the post as idiotic and brash. I think NGD needs to shape up, their customer team is quite poor, their balance team is drifting way out of line, hunters, warlocks, and warjurers have become amazing, and everything has been F****** up (thats for another thread though :P).

But ya NGD needs to shape up.

Klutu · 04-23-2010, 09:55 PM

I don't consider that review to be a proper review.

You don't learn a game in 45 minutes with a lvl 3 character running around the warzone on a Horse

The only pro's related to RO was of the Models.. and Animations.. are you serious? lol

the combat system might not be what it use to be. But it's still the main reason i stick around in RO.
It's Basic but it's Good

instead of every WoW clone out there with jumping and dramatic attack motions

Rare RvR/PvP

im sure lvl 3 RvR/PvP battles are quite rare.. theres always something going on any server people just need to seek it out.

i don't also consider Mmo Sanctuary to be much of a Gaming Site..

There Game Reviews are all of Mainstream Games.. WoW LotR's Age of Conan Call of Duty -

NGD does need to wake up and start listening to some of the demands and needs

Brihtwulf · 04-23-2010, 10:02 PM

The only experience we spent in the game was NOT with that particular level 3 character. We had two separate writers testing the mechanics of the game. That one experience was only a single instance of what we encountered. Information was also used that was gained from speaking to a number of players in the game. This wasn't just a haphazard review by any means.

Dannboy · 04-24-2010, 06:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mattdoesrock

What's the phrase..?

"Inb4lock"

?

That doesnt work with mods =P
But yes, that is the right phrase

Brihtwulf · 04-23-2010, 09:54 PM

I have to say that this treatment from the staff at NGD is insulting. It's insulting to the writers, insulting to the players of this game, and I take it as a direct insult that they would be so quick to close a topic about their review but so slow to respond to any public relations inquiries.

Gideon_Slack · 04-23-2010, 10:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brihtwulf

I have to say that this treatment from the staff at NGD is insulting. It's insulting to the writers, insulting to the players of this game, and I take it as a direct insult that they would be so quick to close a topic about their review but so slow to respond to any public relations inquiries.

Honestly man, they prioritized your mickey-mouse website.

NGD: 2 guys (sorry "writers") and a cheap hosting account? Yeah, we'll be right on that (*snicker*, goes back to running a real company).

Brihtwulf · 04-23-2010, 10:24 PM

We have a staff of 7 people, thank you very much. Did I mention we get roughly 1,000 visits a week currently, and that's on the rise? Our site is dedicated to the free speech and ideas of online gamers, and an action like this is insulting. Our staff is mostly composed of veteran writers, some former game industry employees, and other journalists. Please don't make judgements on things you don't know anything about for the sole means of trying to dispairage our work.

Just because something is fairly new doesn't mean it's unimportant. If we're worth the time of larger companies like Sony Online Entertainment and Cryptic Studios with our publishings, then NGD Studios has no reason to treat our site disrespectfully.

Thank you.

04-23-2010, 09:08 PM	#1
WhateverUSMC Initiate Join Date: Dec 2008 Location: Peterborough, Ontario Posts: 189	Recent Review; A Cold Shot of (Needed) Water I am somewhat in shock with the fact that the thread (with the link to the review) was closed. In reality, what was said in it was fairly accurate, and didn't contain anything that the players here haven't said before. We now have a review that matches most, if not all, of the players complaints, and it just gets swept under a rug. Am I really the only one who has a problem with this? The players get ignored. The reviewer gets silenced (5). __________________ o Q o (WM), Martok (WM), Wyatt Earp (53), T'Pol (52), P'Tak (57), Rotarrin (38)

04-23-2010, 09:24 PM	#2
Mattdoesrock Count Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: England, UK. Posts: 1,055	What's the phrase..? "Inb4lock" ? __________________ MattdoesJOKE_#40_NOT_FOUND RA / Hor... Haven?

04-23-2010, 09:37 PM	#3
Bladnoch Initiate Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: England Posts: 199	Wow, that is a shock... I thought it was a pretty refreshing and honest review too - there was no ranting, no intended insults and no one completely and utterly disagreed with it, except NGD themselves, a reaction that speaks some volumes. :/ P.S. NGD, if you're going to close a thread which gives a less than average review of your game, do not stick it in the Complaint Book. There is a line between insults and harsh critique. A thin line, but please recognise it and tranfer the thread back to General Discussion...where it belongs. __________________ Ra Sytris - Starpulse Lvl 25 Horus Syrtis - Bladnoch Lvl 20 Horus Alsius - Goatus Lvl 37

04-23-2010, 09:55 PM	#5
Klutu Baron Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Canada Posts: 714	I don't consider that review to be a proper review. You don't learn a game in 45 minutes with a lvl 3 character running around the warzone on a Horse The only pro's related to RO was of the Models.. and Animations.. are you serious? lol the combat system might not be what it use to be. But it's still the main reason i stick around in RO. It's Basic but it's Good instead of every WoW clone out there with jumping and dramatic attack motions Rare RvR/PvP im sure lvl 3 RvR/PvP battles are quite rare.. theres always something going on any server people just need to seek it out. i don't also consider Mmo Sanctuary to be much of a Gaming Site.. There Game Reviews are all of Mainstream Games.. WoW LotR's Age of Conan Call of Duty - NGD does need to wake up and start listening to some of the demands and needs __________________ Ramsli Klutu

04-23-2010, 09:49 PM	#4
Minorian Master Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Peterborough ON Posts: 597	As soon as something goes against NGD, they just get rid of it. Whenever someone gives some criticism it is responded to often harshly, sometimes banning, sometimes dismissing the post as idiotic and brash. I think NGD needs to shape up, their customer team is quite poor, their balance team is drifting way out of line, hunters, warlocks, and warjurers have become amazing, and everything has been F****** up (thats for another thread though :P). But ya NGD needs to shape up.

04-23-2010, 10:02 PM	#6
Brihtwulf Pledge Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 36	The only experience we spent in the game was NOT with that particular level 3 character. We had two separate writers testing the mechanics of the game. That one experience was only a single instance of what we encountered. Information was also used that was gained from speaking to a number of players in the game. This wasn't just a haphazard review by any means.

04-23-2010, 09:54 PM	#8
Brihtwulf Pledge Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 36	I have to say that this treatment from the staff at NGD is insulting. It's insulting to the writers, insulting to the players of this game, and I take it as a direct insult that they would be so quick to close a topic about their review but so slow to respond to any public relations inquiries.

04-23-2010, 10:24 PM	#10
Brihtwulf Pledge Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 36	We have a staff of 7 people, thank you very much. Did I mention we get roughly 1,000 visits a week currently, and that's on the rise? Our site is dedicated to the free speech and ideas of online gamers, and an action like this is insulting. Our staff is mostly composed of veteran writers, some former game industry employees, and other journalists. Please don't make judgements on things you don't know anything about for the sole means of trying to dispairage our work. Just because something is fairly new doesn't mean it's unimportant. If we're worth the time of larger companies like Sony Online Entertainment and Cryptic Studios with our publishings, then NGD Studios has no reason to treat our site disrespectfully. Thank you.