GameSamba's hall of shameless condemnation

[erttzzadfk]

Originally Posted by Shwish

The name "Penis" in the spammers and trolls section made me lol.

Temporarily banning these people isn't going do anything. I'm personally glad GS is doing this, it wont fix the problem but its better than doing nothing about it.

1+

Out of here again. I already know all aspects and arguments about this whole topic from the german forum where nothing was changed by gamigo.
So it'll be very interesting for me to see the development of the two different publishers and their communitys.
Hope GameSamba did right with this list. I really think so !

[kmdk]

Originally Posted by PT_DaAr_PT

Seriously, purple fever carriers?

This ...O.o .. common ,.... purple event meant to spread purple fever....

[TheBarbarianAlsius]

Fight fire with Fire

[blood-raven]

Originally Posted by erttzzadfk

...

If you ban someone for cheating i'm fine with it but a public crucifixion is a thing of a dark past.

It's disturbing you think it's a good idea.

[VandaMan]

I can see both sides. Firstly I'd like to be clear - adding trolls, purple fever carriers, spammers, and harassers is a bit silly and accomplishes nothing. However I can get on board with making it public when people abuse bugs and such to gain war/pvp advantages.

These people cheat to gain an advantage, to gain RP or to win. We can't take away the actual victories or place on the high scores list they've gained by cheating, but we can make sure everyone knows how they got them. Not that the rankings truly matter, but I think if I were competitive enough to care (we do have players who are), and the guys above me in rankings had cheated to get there, I should know about it.

When you cheat to gain items, we take the items away. When you cheat to gain victories, we should take those away too.

[Evangeline]

Originally Posted by VandaMan

I can see both sides. Firstly I'd like to be clear - adding trolls, purple fever carriers, spammers, and harassers is a bit silly and accomplishes nothing. However I can get on board with making it public when people abuse bugs and such to gain war/pvp advantages.

These people cheat to gain an advantage, to gain RP or to win. We can't take away the actual victories or place on the high scores list they've gained by cheating, but we can make sure everyone knows how they got them. Not that the rankings truly matter, but I think if I were competitive enough to care (we do have players who are), and the guys above me in rankings had cheated to get there, I should know about it.

When you cheat to gain items, we take the items away. When you cheat to gain victories, we should take those away too.

if people cheat for fun, we should take fun away too

a good way to do that is implementing alot of rules, and publishing a hall of shame on forums

i'd like to add that daar's post is a bit ironic, because he is basically crying that gamesamba has too many rules that wouldnt exist if they hadnt come place them, and saying how they arent needed but in Raven, he was one of the many that persued the way of the witchhunt, always recording people and trying to get them banned by making up idiotic excuses and showing vid to gm or putting on youtube, such as "save guard glitching" or "precise block animation bug abusing" those were my favourite ones, and if i recall you were banned for at least a day for trolling, the amount of personal attacks was too damn high but you held on to gameamba tightly always crying to a gm

My question doesnt need to be answered but if you wanna answer, why the sudden change in behaviour? all of a sudden there are too many rules?

[blood-raven]

[VandaMan]

Originally Posted by nohan

if people cheat for fun, we should take fun away too

Yes, yes we should. I'm not sure if you're trying to be sarcastic here or not, but we most certainly should (and already do) "take fun away" from people who cheat. We call this a "ban."

[Evangeline]

Originally Posted by VandaMan

Yes, yes we should. I'm not sure if you're trying to be sarcastic here or not, but we most certainly should (and already do) "take fun away" from people who cheat. We call this a "ban."

nop not sarcastic at all

[gluffs]

This matter is just another perfect example off Gamesamba having their own
rules and NGD has theirs. On this forum we are not allowed to name cheaters
or hang out troublemakers ( and i think that is a good thing) instead we are
supposed to report it. But heck on Gamesamba forum the GM´s themself put
out the names...

Really can anyone from ngd make a statement if you are working on a
common ruleset or we just need to live in limbo and hope we dont brake any
off gamesambas wierd rules and get banned?

Like the insta ban for savecamping, what is considerd camping and not in the
eyes off gamesamba? Will i get banned for passing the save and i defend
myself from an attacker that stands at save or is that ok (castle saves at this
example), or is it up to the GM on duty if he is in a good or bad mood to
decide? From what ive seen and heard the GM´s interprets the rules based on
their own personal opinion and what mood they are in. And it often feels like
they really dont know either and just act on what they belive is correct or not....

Really, this is getting retarded.